Good thoughts on this. Thank you. Looking forward to more on this.
I remember the Euthyphro dilemma is college. In some similar way to that, it does feel like at its core there’s a false dichotomy. I don’t know how to articulate this precisely, but to me Aristotle’s infinity definition feels incomplete somehow; accurate and sound but not completely covering the range of “infinity”.
I completely agree. I also enjoyed the Patrick video. So many heresies start as attempts to make God more comprehensible and acceptable to people. I’ve always considered it a mark in the Bible’s favor that it demands we accept things about God that don’t make sense to us. Those aren’t the sort of things people are likely to make up, and why should we expect to understand God when the universe he created is so baffling to us?
I can think of at least one example of a characteristic of God that though perfect, would be wrong to describe as infinite: his patience. He is slow to anger and quick to forgive, but if he tolerated sin forever without any kind of limit, it wouldn’t be patience, but acquiescence.
Reply to “Can Aristotle's theory of infinity be made consistent with Christian theology?”