Communicate with WikiCritic

All comments here were published elsewhere by their authors, under a licence that allows us to carry them. We will honour requests to retract submissions, and it is possible that our AI agent may misrepresent (and ought to fix) something imported. Communicate these issues with us here.

Our policies

If you wrote a comment and wish it removed from WikiCritic, say so and we will remove it.

What removal does

The comment stops being displayed and its grades stop counting—it leaves every average on every article, at once. Nothing you wrote goes on influencing a score after you have retracted it.

Its address keeps working and says the comment was withdrawn. We do not delete the page, because a dead link is indistinguishable from a site that lost its records—and other reviews that agreed or disagreed with yours point at that address.
If you believe a review breaks the law or is defamatory of you, let us know. We will consider these issues on a case-by-case basis.
If there is something wrong with how your comment was imported, let us know and we will try to make it right.
If you have a feature request or bug report, this is a good place to submit that.

Tell us

The address of the page this is about Our address for it if you have it; the address where it was originally published works too. Leave it empty for a feature request or a bug report about the site itself.

Which is this? I wrote it and I am withdrawing it. Always honoured, once we can see it is yours—choose this and we will ask how.

We have no accounts, so anyone could claim to be you. Either of these settles it, and they work because only you can do them.

I have posted a note where the review lives, saying it should come down and naming it. Give us that address: I have taken the review down from my own site, or removed the licence line from it. We will check.

It is about me and I object to it. Read by a person. It is defamatory, infringing, or subject to a court order. Read by a person, quickly. You have imported my review inaccurately. A grade, the article, my name, the date—something does not match what I published. Fixed, not removed. A feature request or a bug report. Something is broken, or something ought to exist. Something else.

Tell us about it, in your own words Anything you want to add — optional What is wrong with it What is wrong with it What we got wrong, and what it should say What is broken, or what should exist A sentence is enough. You need not give a reason. “This is mine and I want it down” is enough, and so is nothing at all. Say what the review claims and why it is wrong. Say what the review claims, why it is unlawful, and in what jurisdiction if that matters. Quote what our copy says and what your original says. We fix the record; we do not remove the review. What you did, what happened, and what you expected instead. How to reach you —optional We keep no accounts and hold no address for you otherwise. Without one we cannot write back, though you will still get a link to follow this request. I acknowledge that the words I type above, and WikiCritic's response to us, will be readable by anyone on an anonymized web address. My contact details are not shown there.